Back in May 2023, while most of us were thinking about graduation open houses and the first warm weekend at the lake, Gov. Tim Walz signed a big elections bill at the end of the legislative session. Tucked inside it was a promise. Minnesota’s 10 electoral votes would go to whoever wins the most votes for president across the whole country.
Most of us never noticed. I certainly didn’t. It didn’t change a thing about how we voted in 2024.
That’s by design. The law is sitting in a drawer, waiting for enough other states to sign the same promise.
On November 3, voters in five states moved that drawer a lot closer to opening.
What The Compact Is, In Plain English
Start with something a lot of us learned wrong in civics class. The Constitution doesn’t say a state has to give all its electoral votes to whoever wins that state. Article II says each state legislature decides how its electors get chosen. Winner-take-all is just state law. Maine and Nebraska already do it differently.
The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact uses that power. It’s an agreement among states, and it works like this:
Each member state passes the same law.
Nothing changes until the member states together hold at least 270 electoral votes. That’s a majority of the 538 total Electoral College votes, the same number it takes to win the presidency.
Once they cross 270, every member state gives all of its electoral votes to the candidate who won the most votes nationwide, across all 50 states and Washington, D.C.
The Electoral College stays. The national vote count decides who it elects.
Here’s what that looks like at home. If the compact were active, Minnesota’s 10 electors would go to the national winner, even if Minnesota voted the other way. That cuts both ways, and it should. In 2024, Donald Trump won the national popular vote. Under the compact, Minnesota’s electors would have gone to him.
That’s the point. One person, one vote, counted the same in Chaska as in Phoenix, Pittsburgh or Milwaukee.
Why It’s An Improvement
Five of our 47 presidents took office without winning the most votes nationwide. Every four years, campaigns pour their time, money and attention into a handful of closely divided states. Everyone else gets treated as already counted.
Under a national popular vote, a vote in Chaska is worth exactly as much as a vote in Philadelphia. When every vote counts the same, every voter is worth asking for. Having to earn every vote, from many different kinds of people, can have a moderating effect on our political rhetoric.
Where The Count Stands Today
Eighteen states and the District of Columbia have passed the compact. Together they hold 222 electoral votes:
California: 54
New York: 28
Illinois: 19
New Jersey: 14
Virginia: 13
Washington: 12
Massachusetts: 11
Colorado: 10
Maryland: 10
Minnesota: 10
Oregon: 8
Connecticut: 7
New Mexico: 5
Hawaii: 4
Maine: 4
Rhode Island: 4
Delaware: 3
Vermont: 3
District of Columbia: 3
Total: 222
The newest member is Virginia. Gov. Abigail Spanberger signed it in April.
That leaves the compact 48 electoral votes short.
Forty-eight.
What Changed On November 3
A “trifecta” is political shorthand for one party holding the governor’s office and both chambers of the legislature. It matters because a bill like this needs three yeses: the House, the Senate and the governor’s signature.
On Election Day, Democrats won six new trifectas: Arizona, Michigan, Minnesota, Nevada, Pennsylvania and Wisconsin. Come January, Democrats will hold 22 trifectas, the most since before 1984, according to the National Conference of State Legislatures.
Some of these flips were a long time coming. Arizona Democrats won both chambers and the governor’s office for the first time since 1966. Pennsylvania voters elected a Democratic state Senate majority for the first time in more than three decades. In Nevada, Attorney General Aaron Ford unseated Gov. Joe Lombardo.
Now look at that list again. Minnesota is already in the compact. So is every one of the 16 states that already had a Democratic trifecta before this election.
That leaves five states with brand-new trifectas that have not yet passed the compact:
Pennsylvania (19 electoral votes): Gov. Josh Shapiro, reelected
Michigan (15): Gov.-elect Jocelyn Benson
Arizona (11): Gov. Katie Hobbs, reelected
Wisconsin (10): Gov.-elect David Crowley
Nevada (6): Gov.-elect Aaron Ford
Total: 61
222 plus 61 is 283.
The compact needs 270.
The Math, In One Paragraph
Here’s the short version: Among these five states, Pennsylvania and Michigan are both must-haves. Together they add 34. After that, any two of Arizona, Wisconsin and Nevada get the compact over the line. Pennsylvania, Michigan, Wisconsin and Nevada alone would bring it to 272.
So why push for all five?
Because 272 is one bad election away from zero. Until July 20 of a presidential election year, any member state can pull out by repealing its law. If the compact sits at 272 and one small state flips and repeals, the whole thing switches off for everyone. And after the 2030 census, electoral votes get reshuffled among the states. Several big member states are expected to lose a seat or two. A cushion protects the work.
The group behind the compact, National Popular Vote, says it already has sponsors lined up in all five states and expects bills to be filed before or early in the 2027 sessions. Its senior consultant, Patrick Rosenstiel, told Fox News he’s confident the campaign has “multiple paths to secure the 48 electoral votes required.”
The deadline that matters: To govern the 2028 election, the compact must be in effect in states holding at least 270 electoral votes on July 20, 2028.
That’s 20 months away. Legislatures in four states convene in January. Nevada convenes on February 1.
The Fight Ahead
Let’s be honest about what comes next. A trifecta doesn’t mean every legislator in the majority votes yes, and some of these new majorities are thin.
Once the compact hits 270, it will be in court. Critics like Hans von Spakovsky, a former Federal Election Commission member, argue it needs approval from Congress under the Constitution’s Compact Clause, and that states outside the compact could sue. That case could go all the way to the Supreme Court. Supporters argue that Article II authorizes states to allocate their electors this way and that congressional consent is unnecessary. Critics disagree, and courts could ultimately decide the issue.
That’s a real fight. We’ll have it when we get there. We can’t get there without the 48.
And this isn’t a one-party idea, no matter how it gets framed. The compact has passed 44 legislative chambers in 24 states over the years. Right here in Minnesota, former Republican Rep. Pat Garofalo of Farmington signed on as a sponsor. Remember, the last national popular vote winner was a Republican.
What You Can Do This Week
Most of us know somebody in one of these five states. Your cousin in Ann Arbor. Your college roommate in Tempe. Your brother-in-law outside Pittsburgh. Your old coworker in Eau Claire. Your kid who moved to Reno.
They’re the ones who can make this happen. Legislators listen to their own constituents, not to Minnesotans.
So here’s the ask:
Send this article. Text it, email it, post it in the family group chat. Pennsylvania, Michigan, Arizona, Wisconsin and Nevada. (I’ll be sending it to my brother in Pennsylvania.)
Ask them to find their legislators. Every state has a lookup. Search for your state government’s website. It takes about a minute with a home address.
Ask them to contact three people: Their state representative, their state senator and their governor. A phone call is best. An email is good. Both is better.
Give them the words. Something like this works:
Hi, my name is ___ and I live in ___. I am a constituent. I’m asking Representative/Senator ___ to co-sponsor and vote for the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact in the 2027 session. Every vote for president should count the same, no matter which state you live in. Thank you.
For the governor’s office, the ask is simple: Make the compact a priority, and sign it when it reaches your desk.
Do it now. The best time to reach a legislator is before bills are filed and committee chairs are set. That window is open right now, between the election and the January gavel.
We did our part here in 2023. Our 10 votes are already in the drawer.
Now it’s their turn. Make the call. Send the link. Ask one person in one of those five states to pick up the phone.
Forty-eight votes. Five states. One neighbor at a time.
Chaska Protests
Every Friday from 3:00–4:00 p.m. at the corner of Chaska Blvd. and Chestnut Street (Highway 41) [Map]
Every Saturday from 1-2 pm at the corner of Hazeltine Boulevard and Highway 41 (Chestnut) [Map]
Chanhassen Protests
Every Saturday: 1st & 3rd Saturdays from 10-11am at Pedestrian Bridge over Highway 5.
Park at Discovery United Methodist Church. We have permission to park there.
2nd, 4th and 5th Saturday from 10-11am at W 78th and Kerber Boulevard.
Sign library is available.
Norwood Young America
Every Sunday, 11 a.m.–12 p.m. (Line up at the bike path south of Highway 212 and Faxon.)
Victoria
Every Wednesday from 4:30-5:30 pm on the corner of Highway 5 and Victoria Drive/County Rd 11.
Waconia
Every Saturday from 11:30-12:30 pm at Highway 5 and County Road 10 in front of the Starbucks and Jersey Mike’s. [Map]
SW Protectors
Every first and third Tuesday from 6:30 – 8:00 pm. It’s no cost and come and go as you like.
Please do buy something to eat or drink, though, to support our venue, which is The Golden Kitchen and is located at 207 N Chestnut Street #110 in Chaska. [Map]




Great information, thank you David!